10 black eyeliners review -makeup

Was out shopping and lots of makeup was on sale. I ended up buying items and 1 more brown eyeliner. Almost wanted to buy a black one but I recalled having a few other black liners. Somehow I could not recall exactly what liner I have. It is like blank. Oddly my brain is convincing myself to buy another eyeliner because there is a 20% sale. Oh well.

Happily came home only to find that I have 10 black eyeliners from all brands in all forms. 9 coloured eyeliners... Amazing my makeup journey and search has been.
I know how to properly test them before making my purchase.
Rub them with oil from face, some water and just your finger. I know it sounds gross but is rather give it a proper test than regretting later on.

1. Korres eyeliner pencil $22~after discount
Totally did not last both smudge test and water test. Maybe good for smudging and doing smokey eye look. 100% natural base with herbs and vitamins so I guess I have to learn to appreciate its natural ingredients.
Water : 0/3
Oil :1/3
Smudge: 0/3

2. Urban Decay Glide on Eye pencil $25
It did not move much after these tests. Awesome!
Water: 3/3
Oil: 2/3
Smudge: 3/3

3. FACE it All about eyeliner (Korea) $17~
One of my favorite liquid eyeliner after numerous tests. The most it will flake off and do not smudge.
Water: 3/3
Oil: 3/3
Smudge: 3/3

4. Yibi liquid eyeliner (Korea) $15~
Fave too!! It may be a bit stiff if I apply too many layers.
Water: 3/3
Oil: 3/3
Smudge: 3/3

5. Shisheido Eyeliner pencil crayon $30~ (Japan)
Not sure why I got this. Probably wanted to try a good brand but this kinda disappoints. I hardly use this due to its unreliability. Good for smudging...
Water: 1/3
Oil: 1/3
Smudge: 0/3

6. Revlon Colorstay Liquid Liner $14~
Liquid is not intense enough. Maybe cos mine is bit old.
Water: 0/3
Oil: 2/3
Smudge: 3/3

7. INuovi Fluidliner waterproof (Germany) $20
Not too sure about this.
Water: 1/3
Oil: 2/3
Smudge: 2/3

8. Mabelline Gel Liner ($20~)
Stays put pretty well. Quite like using this other than that I have to use a separate brush to apply.
Water: 2/3
Oil: 3/3
Smudge: 3/3

9. Bourjois Paris Sparkling Eyeliner
Only fun thing is that it sparkles. Other than that I have to pray that it stays...
Water: 1/3
Oil: 1/3
Smudge: 1/3

10. MAC Technakohl liner eyeliner kajal
(62RM)
Bought this from Johor Malaysia from a Mac store. I kinda doubt it's quality and authenticity... Does not work well enough for me.
Water: 2/3
Oil: 2/3
Smudge: 2/3

Prices all in SGD.

Review of my colour eyeliners coming up next time.